Wednesday, April 23, 2025

German Anabaptist Settlements in Western Ukraine, Walter Kuhn, 1955

Deutsche Täufersiedlungen im westukrainischen Raume by Walter Kuhn (Zeitschrift Fur Ostforschung; Lander und Volker im ostlichen Mitteleuropa)



4. D i e E i n w a n d e r u n g d e r W e i c h s e l - M e n n o n i t en

p490

In the Netherlands, after the catastrophe of Münster in 1535, the older Anabaptist movement was named after its leader named after its leader Menno Simons.  During the Mennonite persecutions of the Spanish period (until 1572), a large number of them fled to the Vistula estuary around Danzig.  They were experienced in draining the marshes; they were gladly accepted and carried out an enormous dike-building and colonization project and quickly achieved economic prosperity.  From the Vistula delta they very soon advanced up the Vistula valley as far as Thorn.  Unlike the Hutterites, their social structure was purely peasant, based on individual property and democratic cooperation of the "neighbors". Economically, besides the cultivation of cereals in the humid lowlands, these Mennonite engaged in dairy farming and cheese-making 22 in accordance with the custom of their homeland (Dutch lowlands).  In order to avoid any stronger ties to a landlord, the Dutch Mennonites rented their land only on a temporary lease, in return for comparatively high monetary payments, rejecting any kind of sharecropping.

Already in the 16th century the spatial expansion of the Vistula-Mennonites came to a standstill.  The development of the Netzebruch by Frederick the Great, for which they had just the right special knowledge, gave them the opportunity to participate in colonization work.  Emissaries of the Mennonites from the Kulmer Lowlands approached the head of the Netze establishment, Chief Finance Councilor Franz Balthasar von Schönberg von Brenckenhoff.  With the councilor’s backing, 16 families settled in Brenkenhofswalde, 13 in Franzthal and 8 in two neighboring small settlements, all in 1765.  These exclusively Mennonite villages were situated just west of Driesen.  Somewhat later followed Neu-Dessau, east of the city, where 12 Mennonite families from the Danzig Lowlands formed only a minority in the village.23   Very quickly, the Mennonites became exemplary leaders in the lowland settlement of Netzebruch.

Soon after, the Mennonites resumed their migration up the Vistula River.  In 1776 they settled Deutsch-Kazun west of Warsaw, opposite the mouth of the Bug into the Vistula 24; and at the end of the 18th century Deutsch-Wymyśle was established near Plock.25  There was thus a modest revival of the Mennonite colonization of Prussian lands and the same thing happened a little later, on a much larger scale, when they undertook to establish settlements in the Russian Empire.  Already in 1766, Vistula Germans were involved in the first large immigration under Catherine II, in the very area under discussion, in the construction of the German enclave of Bielowies in the Konotop district of Gubernia Chernigov.  In addition to the West German and Mecklenburg majority there also came Lutheran and Catholic Germans from the Danzig Werder who did not trave; by ship via St. Petersburg, but came overland in a separate trek.26  The villages of Groß-Werder, Klein-Werder and Rundewiese in the Bielowieser Group are named after their homeland.27  The implementation of the colonization work was in the hands of the Governor General of Little Russia, Count Rumyantsov.

As a result of the first partition of Poland, a large number of the Vistula Mennonites came under Prussian control and thereafter saw state decrees that threatened their freedom of military service and limited the possibility of expansion.  Many therefore followed the Russian government's call in 1786 for them to settle in the in the Black Sea region and in 1789 founded the "old colony" on the Dnieper bend near Chortitza.  Economically, however, they had to change completely from cattle breeding in the humid lowlands to sheep breeding and later to wheat growing in the rainless black steppe.  Closely related to this process is the calling of the Vistula Mennonites to the part of the Ukraine under the ownership of Count Prot Potocki.

Like other Polish magnates in the time of King Stanislaus Poniatowski, Potocki was eager to establish industrial enterprises by bringing in Western, especially German, experts.28  Thus, around 1780, he established a number of German textile factories in the small town of Machnówka in an effort to exploit the German textile trades.29  In the surrounding area, he endeavored to rebuild the villages and develop agriculture in these areas that had become desolate in the battles of the 17th century.  In 1791 he settled a group of Vistula Mennonites on the steppe north of the village of Michalin on favorable conditions, similar to that which they were accustomed to in the Gdansk region.  Each family received land according to its capacity, from 18 Morgen to 3 kulmische Hufen, in addition to 100 Polish guilders for travel expenses.  As land for the preacher, cemetery, church, and school Potocki donated 30 Morgen.  In addition, he donated two years’ salary to the preacher of 250 guldens and gave a loan of 3,000 guldens for the church building.  The survey of the land was carried out by a surveyor provided by the count but in the manner familiar to the Mennonites: Deutsch-Michalin became a group of individual farms (Einzelhöfen).30

Only two years later, during the second partition of Poland, the area was assigned to the Kiev Gubernia.  The Russian authorities initially levied the same poll taxes on the Germans as on the serf peasants.  In 1804, after long legal struggles, the Michaliners were finally recognized as colonists in accordance with the 1763 Manifesto of Catherine II, and by the hand of Alexander I they were even refunded the additional taxes they had already paid.31  From then on, the colony enjoyed a good development and formed an important link between the Vistula and Black Sea Mennonites.32

Shortly before the favorable outcome of these legal wranglings, some of the Michaliners, despairing of success, moved away and in 1802 settled south of Ostróg, forming the colony of Karlswald (Karolswald, Polish: Holendry Slobodzkie, after the neighboring village of Slobodka).33  Here in the humid Wilja/Vilia River lowlands, the Mennonites were able to return to their familiar way of farming: breeding of Dutch and Swiss cattle and the production of butter and cheese.  In addition, they also they also engaged in textile weaving.  In the following period they multiplied rapidly and founded additional villages.  Reiswitz-Wadzeck 34 mentions in 1821 two villages with a total of 38 families; in addition to Karlswald was probably Antoniendorf (Antonówka) or Jadwinin.  In 1828 the daughter colony to Karlswald, named Karlsberge, was established.35  Two more villages, Fürstendorf (Lesnaja, Nikitska) and Fürstenthal (Kustarna), were established later although we don’t know exactly when.  These six settlements 36 together formed a cohesive group of remote German-Mennonite villages.

In the years 1806 to 1818 came a second wave of Vistula-Mennonites to Volhynia, some from the Schwetz lowlands, some from the Netzebruch.37  However, we have detailed information about only one of their establishments.  Founded in 1811 by the nobleman Waclaw Borejko, Zofjowka 38 was settled north of the small town of Wysock far to the north on the Horyn River, in the middle of the Polish marshes.  21 families (Beyer, 2 Buller, Böse, 2 Dirks, 3 Voth, Nachtigall, 2 Nickel, 2 Pankratz, Richard, 4 Sperling, Unruh and Zielke)39 leased 33 farmsteads, for each of which they paid the high annual interest of 120 Polish guilders.  In return, they were exempt from all other burdens, specifically compulsory service to the landlord.  They also had freedom of trade without having to join a guild, free choice of judges and freedom of religion.  For school and cemetery, they received half a half Hufe free of charge.  For the first two difficult years, the landowner advance 200 guilders to each house.  The Privilege shows even better than that of Machnówka (Michalin), the exact transfer of the customary Gdansk lowlands to Volhynia.

A second colony of this group, not known in detail, was located near the small town of Rafalówka on the Styr River northeast of Luck.  An additional third colony was probably Waldheim (Waltajem, later Solianka) 30 km southwest of Novograd Wolynsk.40  Certainly also the neighboring Dosilorf (Zabara), for which [Alfred Karasek;Kurt Lück] gives the time of foundation "before 1807" 41, also belongs to the same context.

The following two decades brought a series of resettlements of the of the Netzebrücher 42, about whose causes and course we know only little.  The Zofjówkaers moved before 182843, leaving their land to German Lutherans.  These Zofjówkaers went to "Ostrowa" in the county of Luck, which is probably synonymous with Józefin, 30 km northeast of Luck, and still included the Zofjówka area to the east.  For Józefin I could find the 1936 settlement contract of the Mennonites in the village Schulzenamt 44 .  For Zofjówka the memory of the Mennonites is preserved in the tradition of the Jews and Ukrainians who later inhabited the village.45  The location of the colony of "Wola", which the Mennonites settled after leaving the area of Rafalówka,46 is uncertain.  Wola may be the Mennonite settlement of Horodyszcze 40 km wnw. of Równe, for which Lück gives as the year of foundation "before 1817.47  The Melanienwald colony was settled on the territory of the later colony named Kruchy, 12 km northwest of  Równe.  Kruchy was occupied by Lutherans who settled on the area of their Mennonite predecessors.  We cannot give a more specific date in regard to the establishment of this colony.48   

22) H. Penner, Ansiedlung Mennonitischer Niederländer im Weichselmündungsgebiet von der Mitte des 16. Jahrhunderts bis zum Beginn der Preußischen Zeit. Weierhof i. Pf. 1940.

23) B. H. Unruh, “Die Mennoniten in der Neumark.”  In: Christlicher Gemeindekalender für das Jahr 1941, hrsg.  von der Konferenz der süddeutschen Mennoniten und der Konferenz der ost- und westpreußischen Mennonitengemeinden, Jg. 50, S. 58—76.

24) A. Breyer, “Deutsche Gaue in Mittelpolen”.  In: Deutsche Monatshefte in Polen, Jg. 1934/35, S. 398.

25) B. H. Unruh, Die niederländisch-niederdeutschen Hintergründe der mennonitischen Ostwanderungen: im 16., 18. und 19 Jahrhundert.  S. 172 (according to a notice from Fr. Kliewer): Wymyśle was established in 1792 and Mennonites settled there just a very short time later.

26)  In the language of the Bielowie villages, the dialect of the Upper Hessians prevailed over the Werder Germans (V. Schirmunski, “Die deutschen Kolonien in der Ukraine”. Kharkiv, 1928. p. 20); otherwise, as a result of their isolated location, they were linguistically largely Ukrainized in the 19th century.  As evidence of their origin see J. A. Güldenstädt, Reisen durch Rußland und im Caucasischen Gebürge, hrsg. v. P. S. Pallas. 2. Teil. Petersburg 1791, p. 379: "others are from the area of Danzig and Elbing, and these made the journey here through Poland via Kiev."

27) The mother village to Rundewiese is located 15 km south of Marienwerder in the Vistula lowlands.

28)  This wave of industrialization in Poland, which also created a number of German towns in western Ukraine, created a German social class which, however, quickly faded away.  For general information see Kurt Lück, Deutsche Aufbaukräfte in der Entwicklung Polens.  Plauen i. Vogtland, 1934, bes. S. 309.

29) B. Chlebowski-, Slownik geograficzny Królestwa Polskiego i innych krajów Slovianskich. Warsaw 1880 ff. Vol V, p. 877 ff.

30) Partial summary of the privilege of 1791 in the Slownik geograficzny, Vol X, p. 247 (keyword “Samhorodek”).

31) Russia under Alexander I, a historical magazine, ed. from Henry Stork, Vol. 4, Petersburg and Leipzig 1804. P. 116.

32) [G. L.] Early v. R e i s w i t z - [F.] W a d z e c k, Contributions to the Knowledge of the Mennonite Congregations in Europe and America (Berlin 1821), reports on p. 379 about the settlement "Michelau," "where the West Prussian emigrants as well as the local (= Black Sea) colonists returning to their homeland stay." On p. 377, a family number of 18 is given for Michalin. 33) Slownik geograficzny, Vol. III, p. 844, also P. R. K a u f m a n n , p. 20, and H. S m i t h , p. 28. When other authors, such as W. L jad o w , European Russia in Physical and Ethnographical Relation, Petersburg 1861, state 1783 as the founding year, this could at most refer to the beginnings of immigration to Deutsch-Michalin; the year is probably incorrect.

34) p. 377.

35) Slownik geogr., Vol. III, p. 843.

36) Perhaps Grünthal (Polish: Olendry or Moszczanówka) east of Ostróg also belonged to this Mennonite group. The name Heinrichsdorf, listed in the Ostroger group by H. Smith, p. 160, is uncertain; perhaps it is the German name for Jadwinin? 

37) The most reliable, because oldest, information about them is found in a community report of the Waldheim colony in the Molotschna Mennonite area, written in 1848 (M. W o l t n e r, The Community Reports of 1848 of the German Settlements on the Black Sea, Leibbrandt Collection, Vol. 4, Leipzig 1941. p. 158): “The 68 families of this colony came from the Volhynia Governorate, specifically from the following places: 1) From the Ostrowa colony, in the Lutsk District, on the estates of the nobleman Michael Bitschkowskij, where they had come from the Rokonosch District, not far from the town of Wissotzk, from the manor of the nobleman Watzlaf Vorainy; 2) From the Wolla colony, on the estates of the nobleman Ignat Bitschkowskij, where they had come from the Count Olisarow's manor near the small town of Ravalowka in the Lutsk District, and 3) from the Nowograd Volhynsk District from the estate of Prince Ljubomirskij. Their mostly deceased fathers, however, migrated to the mentioned places between 1806 and 1818 from the province of Neumark near Driesen and from the village of Schwez in West Prussia." This establishes the origin of the Mennonites. The difficulty lies only in identifying the places in Volhynia mentioned under 2) and 3).

38) The German version of the settlement agreement of April 19, 1811, printed by A. Karasek — K. Lück, The German Settlements in Volhynia, History, Folklore, Life Issues (German Gaue in the East, Vol. 3)Die deutschen  Siedlungen  in Wolhynien, Geschichte, Volkskunde,  Lebensfragen  (Deutsche  Gaue  im Osten, Bd 3). Plauen i.V. 1931. pp. 22-24.

39) According to a friendly letter from Prof. D. Dr. B. H. Unruh, Karlsruhe, these names indicate origins in the Netzebruch region.

40) According to the Unruh family tradition, Benjamin Unruh, the great-grandfather of Professor B. H. Unruh, emigrated in 1816 with several other families from Franzthal in the Neumark to Waldheim in Volhynia. (B. H. Unruh, The Dutch-Low German Backgrounds . . . , pp. 152 and 155.) Waldheim would therefore be the village in the Nowograd Volhynsk district mentioned in the 1848 municipal report, after whose migrants in 1836 the settlement in the Molotschna region was named Waldheim. H. S m i t h , The Coming . . . , p. 28, attributes the beginnings of Waldheim to those who emigrated from Deutsch-Michalin in 1802, but his information is probably based only on the memories of the American Mennonites.

41) A. Karasek — K. Lück , p. 21.

42) cf. community report of the Waldheim colony in M. W o l t n e r , Community Reports, p. 158.

43) In this year, their contract received a supplement for the Lutherans. See A. Karasek — K. Lück, p. 24.

44) The copy I took at that time, along with my other Volhynian collections, was lost due to the expulsion from Breslau. I seem to remember that the year was 1828, that all the colonist families listed in the treaty had the same names as in the Zofjówka Treaty of 1811, and that a map of the area drawn up before the land division bore the designation "Ostrów."

45) A. Karasek — K. Lück, p. 21. The popular second name of the village, Trochimbrody, was interpreted by the Ukrainians as the German "Trockenbrot" (dry bread), as the Mennonites jokingly called their village.

46) M. W o l t n e r, Gemeindeberichte (Community Reports), p. 159.

47) A. Karasek — K. Lück, p. 21.

48) Own oral survey, 1936.

Tuesday, April 22, 2025

Alexander Voronin's, "About Foreign Settlers in the Southwest Krai"

Alexander Fedoseevich Voronin, in his treatise "About Foreign Settlers in the Southwest Krai", 1873, gives an amazing account of the establishment of the Mennonite colonies in Volyn and Podol.  Some details listed by Voronin are not found anywhere else.  Following is my personal translation of pages 1-6 of Voronin's history.


The beginning of the settlement of foreigners in the southwestern part of the country dates back to the days of the Polish government, in the last days of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth. The first colonists here were sectarians from Western Europe, who left their homeland because of religious persecution and settled in the region, attracted by the extraordinary privileges granted them by rich landowners, who had not enough workers to cultivate their own land.  For example, in 1791 the governor of the Makhnovka and Samgorod estates in the Berdichev district of the Kiev province, Prot Potocki, in Warsaw issued a privilege to 20 families of Mennonites who had come from Holland to settle on the land of the village Samgorodok.  This privilege granted the resettlers significant privileges and benefits.  Potocki obligated to allot the land for each family up to 3 [small pieces of Chelmno measure], and to give 100 zlotys (Polish) free of charge as allowance for transportation to the place of settlement; to give every family in the first year of resettlement loan corn of different kinds for replanting the fields according to the size of the occupied lands and, in addition, 10 корцевъ [unit of measure] for food; to grant the colonists with a loan of 1,000 zlotys per family, without interest, for six years, and with the donation of building material, 10 oaks and 30 pines per family, as well as the donation of stone from the quarry; To maintain the preacher, the cemetery, the church, and the school, 30 morgs were assigned for perpetual free use, and to give the preacher 500 zlotys as a gift during the first two years; in addition, the society was given 3000 zlotys on credit without interest for the construction of the church for 3 years.  For the land plots, the colonists were obliged to pay 3 zlotys per morg.

This fee was determined by the average price of rye and was to be changed every 12 years in accordance with the change in the price of rye, and after 60 years from the conclusion of the contract it was to be finally determined by deduction from the average prices of 12 years and to remain unchanged forever.  Then the colonists were relieved of military service and all duties and tributes to the landlord, committing themselves only to pay the state taxes.  The new settlement was given the name Makhalin (Махалинъ), and Potocki's Privilege was approved in 1781 by King Stanislaus Augustus, and in 1800 it was listed in the land registers of Makhnovsky Poviat.

It was the first foreign colony in the region.  It still exists today (1873).  After the reunification of Polsha, Volyn and Podolia, the Makhnovka Mennonites took Russian citizenship and were enrolled as colonists according to the (ревизскимъ сказкамъ; revision lists).  A part of the Mennonite craftsmen settled in Makhnovka and at the same time were registered as petty bourgeoisie in this place.  At present 44 families comprising 258 souls of both sexes, who on the ground of the mentioned Privilege have in termless use 300 dessiatin from the lands of Samgorod domain and in addition to that they bought 650 dessiatin from neighboring landowners on various occasions.  The men are engaged only in farming and run a farm, owning in families 20 to 50 dessiatin of land. At the last census there were 34 families of mennonites in the Makhnovka village, consisting of 187 souls of both sexes.  They form a special petty bourgeois society and are engaged in different trades and crafts.

After the reunification of the region, the first foreign settlers in it were also Mennonites, who came from Prussia.  In 1801 the owner of the Ostroshkago estate, Prince Karl Yablonovsky, signed a contract with 16 families for their perpetual use from the lands of Slobodka, located in the vicinity of Volyn province. Ostrog, Volyn province, 34 [уволоки] of haymaking lands and undeveloped lands and obliged to give settlers free of charge and on loan for 3 years 200 zlotys per family for the building timber, to give half of the [ ] land for the preacher for indefinite use and to guarantee them not to fulfill any other duties, except those specified in the contract, which they had to fulfill for the benefit of the owner as well as from correction of the recruitment duty.  For their part, the colonists undertook to pay 60 [k.] annually to the proprietor for each morg of haymaking and plowing land, excluding that which is under fallow; they were obliged to buy beverages only [from the estate], to grind bread only [in estate mills], and to submit to the power of the landlord as regards court and punishment, so that he would allow the colonists to choose a foreman from among themselves, who, upon approval of the owner, was to keep order and to administer court between them with the right of the offended person to appeal to the landlord.

Three years later, in 1804, under the same conditions a second colony was founded by newcomers, Antonovka, near the town of Kunev, and in 1817 a third colony under the name of Валъдгойма (Walhoyma [Waldheim]) was founded there.  These colonies quickly grew and, separating from their environment landless families, formed new settlements.  So in 1857 they founded the fourth colony - Yadvinin, and in the last five years of the decade three more colonies: Grundal in 1865, Firstendorf in 1868, and Firstental in 1869.  Registered in the last revision as colonists in all these colonies there are only 120 families of 1524 souls of both sexes.  Settlers of the first colony, Karls-Wald, are still using 608 ½ dessiatin of land indefinitely on the basis of the contract of 1801; the subsequent colonies Jadwinin, Grintal, Firschendorf and Fierstental (together) leased 1,438 dessiatin of land from the Ostroshkago estate's owner (pursuant to independent contracts). The colonies of Antonovka and Вальдъ-Гоймъ (Wald-Hoym), founded on the lands of Kunev’s estate, which were confiscated/ lustrated after the 1831 mutiny into the treasury, received 260 dessiatin as part of the lustration. 


Sunday, March 30, 2025

Maps Detailing Low German Mennonite Colonies in Volyn Governorate

Volyn Governorate of the 19th century Russian Empire covered a large area of land, about 16,216 sq miles/42,000 sq kilometers.  While many of the Low German Mennonite colonies were concentrated near Ostrog, others were not.  It is impossible to find a single map that shows them all while covering such a wide area.  

Using maps from the c1910 3rd Military Mapping Survey of Austria-Hungary, I have put together 2 composite maps of the areas of Volyn Governorate which included Low German Mennonite Colonies.  The 2 composite maps are entitled VOLYN NORTH and VOLYN SOUTH.  These maps do the best job of illustrating the locations of the colonies.  Links to the original maps can be found here: http://lazarus.elte.hu/hun/digkonyv/topo/3felmeres.htm, while a link to a good explanation of this map series can be found here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:3rd_Military_Mapping_Survey_of_Austria-Hungary

This is a very detailed series of maps that label most German/Mennonites colonies as “Kol”.  However, not every colony is marked since some were established after this surveying project was begun.  Also, the spellings of villages, cities, and towns vary from this listing.  These 2 composite maps cover Volyn Governorate in this way:



On the maps, Low German Mennonite colonies are circled in red.  The intention of these maps is to show the Low German colonies, not the Swiss, however, Kutusowka and Neumanovka are included, both circled yellow.  19th century Uyezd capitals are circled blue in order to help with orientation.  Berdichev is circled purple since after 1846 it was located in Podol Governorate and not Volyn.  

Not shown:

  • Novomalin-walde; this colony was located immediately north from Antonowka across the Viliya River
  • Ollika; we do not know the location of Ollika.  There are numerous villages with similar names.  It could very well be the Olyka which is located midway between Rivne and Lutsk.
  • Ostrowa is probably synonymous with Józefin
  • Wolla is likely synonymous with either Sofjówka(II) or Horodyszcze
  • Rosentheim was in the neighborhood of Deutsch-Michalin


Note: Martyni is not circled on the Volyn South map below.  It is located between Antonowka and Jadwanin.






Saturday, March 29, 2025

A Visit to the Former Mennonite Villages in the Netzebruch

 

A Visit to the Former Mennonite Villages in the Netzebruch

Mennonite Hollanders established homes in the Netzebruch – the Netze River lowlands – in the mid-18th century.  At the time, the area was just across the western Polish border into Brandenburg which was controlled by the Kingdom of Prussia.  The Prussian government sought to transform the area into productive farmland by constructing canals to drain the marshy areas as well as importing skilled agriculturalists.  Groningen Old Flemish Mennonites from Jeziorki, Schönsee, and Przechówko established the villages of Brenkenhofswalde and Franzthal, in the mid-1760s.  Brenkenhofswalde, in particular, became an important village in the Old Flemish Mennonite community, and leaders from this village went on to influence Mennonite culture in many ways.

Netzebruch area, circled in red, c100 miles west of the Vistula River valley (1750)[1]

The history of these villages seems to be often neglected perhaps because the settlements were isolated and Mennonites only lived here for slightly less than a century.  More than 100 miles west from the Vistula River, the village grouping was well out of the way from other Polish-Prussian Mennonite settlements.  Basic histories of the villages appear at GAMEO or the Mennonite Lexicon while Mennonite historians such as B.H. Unruh or Herbert Wiebe or Erich Ratzlaff also tell us the fundamentals.  Recently, modern Mennonite researchers such as Adalbert Goertz, Glenn Penner, John D. Richert, or Bob Buller, have begun fleshing out a few more details.

 

Netzebruch, 1803, edited by the author to include outlines of villages Brenkenhofswalde and Franzthal with the Petri Canal (Gilly)[2]

 

The prospect of migrating to Brandenburg was initially explored by Jeziorki Mennonites who were unhappy with their lease, the terms of which had been modified in the early 1760s.  In 1764, delegates from Jeziorki went to Berlin to seek new opportunities and it was there that Franz Balthasar Schonberg von Brenkenhoff invited the Mennonites to the Netzebruch.[3] 

Beginning in the mid-1760s, the Prussians undertook a massive project to reclaim the marshes surrounding the Warthe (Pol: Warte) and Netze (Pol: Noteć) Rivers east from Kustrin (Kostrzyn nad Odrą) to Driesen (Drezdenko).  Colonel Isaak Jacob von Petri formulated the engineering but wanted far too much money for the execution of the project.  Brenkenhoff was then given charge and delivered results for far less than von Petri had estimated.  With all the new land that was reclaimed – some of it wonderfully fertile silt – new colonists needed to be placed.  By the mid-1770s, Brenkenhoff had settled new colonists in 19 completely new villages within the Netzebruch.  Connected to this reclamation project was the 1772-75 Bromberg (Bydgoszcz) Canal project which effectively connected the Oder (at Kustrin) to the Vistula (at Bromberg) via the Netze and Warthe Rivers.[4]

Brenkenhoff’s cost-cutting measures may have had ramifications at least in certain aspects.  For instance, in the Warthebruch near Landsberg (Gorzów Wielkopolski), Brenkenhoff was accused of providing shoddily and hastily built houses for incoming colonists.  Could the same have been true in the Netzebruch?  Could this be why no Mennonite-era structures still stand in Brenkenhofswalde/Franzthal today?  Likely, no, Die Siedlungsentwicklung im Oberen-_und Unteren indicates the Mennonites were provided wood with which they built their own houses.[5] 

The Warthebruch and Neztebruch in 1725, before the 1760s reclamation project[6]

The Warthebruch and Neztebruch in 1816, after completion of von Brenkenhof’s reclamation project.  For instance, note the change in the mouth of the Warthe where it flows into the Oder and the presence of the canal west of Driesen[7]

The Mennonites’ move took place in 1765, at least partially financed by brethren in the Dutch lowlands.  16 families/95 persons settled in Brenkenhofswalde while 19 families/97 persons settled in Franzthal.  Until 1771, neither settlement was taxed.  In 1787 there were 266 Mennonites living in Brenkenhofswalde and Franzthal together.[8]  John D. Richert’s lists compile a total of 742 Mennonites who lived in all the villages (Brenkenhofswalde-Franzthal-Neu Dessau-Rotes Haus) from 1765 until 1834.[9]  During their time in the Netzebruch, these Mennonites’ cattle, dairy, and linen goods, were considered premium products for the area.[10]

I’ve personally been involved with the research of my own Ratzlaff genealogy through Volhynia back to Przechówko for many years.  Working closely with European friends, by 2020 we’d become active in restoring the cemetery at Przechówko, Poland, while in Ukraine, before the 2022 Russian invasion, we’d identified several Hollander houses still standing in the Ostrog area.  Given the close relationship between the Netzebruch villages and both Volhynia and Jeziorki – the lot of them daughters to Przechówko – an excursion to Brenkenhofswalde and Franzthal became inevitable. 

Before the trip, there were indications that no Mennonite structures still stood.  Listings of Mennonite buildings at the Catalog of Monuments of Dutch Colonization in Poland[11] included nothing in the Netzebruch.  Further, Zabytek.pl (Monuments)[12], administered by the National Institute of [Polish] Cultural Heritage, surveyed both villages in decades past, noting the oldest and most significant buildings and none were from the Mennonite era.  Mennonites presumably would have built housebarns similar to those found at Przechówko or Jeziorki but perhaps nothing like that still existed.

In 1805, after the Mennonites had resided in the Netzebruch for just short of half a century, strikingly accurate maps were produced, showing not only the plots of land, but also the canals and houses and churches too.  One can very easily super-impose the maps over a current satellite view and see that 18th century village outlines still exist.  Further, many current structures seem to sit at exactly the same spots where Mennonite buildings did.  Brenkenhofswalde (today = Błotnica) seems to have been heavily re-laid at some point with only the current church and maybe a house or two occupying similar ground as Mennonite structures.  However, in Franzthal (today = Głęboczek) the whole row of houses, as well as the church, seem to sit almost exactly where they did two centuries ago during the Mennonite era.


Brenkenhofwalde and Franzthal; 1805[13]

 

In late August, 2023, I set off for the villages with well-known Polish linguist, Professor Dr. Tomasz Wicherkiewicz, and we spent a day exploring.  Driving west from Przechówko, one encounters all manner of wonders along the beautiful countryside including large orchards, dense forests, and many roadside monuments recognizing the early-autumn harvest season.  Tomasz pointed out to me that the areas into which we were traveling were economically depressed but from the road perhaps this was not obvious.  Areas such as these in western Poland have passed back and forth between German and Polish control.  Numerous red brick German buildings can be seen in the towns and villages but today’s Poles may generally not be too keen on remembering the German chapters of the history.

Arriving in Stare Kurowo (Alt Carbe), the seat of the local gmina government, we met Mayor Magdalena (Magda) Szydełko who would be our guide through Błotnica and Głęboczek; villages both built in the lowlands just off the Noteć River (special thanks to Andrzej Puchacz for connecting us wwith Magda).  Interestingly, both these modern-day Polish names derive from watery terms: błot is a Polish word for mud, głębo- a term for deep (as in: deep water or deep mud).

Stare Kurowo itself stands along the ancient road running from Strzelce Krajeńskie (Friedeberg) to Wieleń (Filehne).  The road in this area travels almost parallel to a railway line which was constructed in the 1840s, some years after the Mennonites left the area.  Both skirt the south edge of the highland.  South of the road and railway, the land slopes downhill toward the Noteć, forming the Netzebruch; the Netzebruch lowlands comprise the area between the road and the river.  It’s a featureless plane gently sloping towards the south which would obviously become quickly inundated with floodwaters if not for the canals.  It was here in the lowlands where we found the villages Błotnica and Głęboczek.

Both villages are almost completely flat east to west, and the ground gently slopes downward from north to south.  At the Stare Kurowo road, the elevation is almost 33 meters above sea level.  By the northern tip of Błotnica the ground has dropped to 28 meters, only 3 or 4 meters above the level of the Noteć.  From the western edge of Błotnica, through Głęboczek, the fluctuation of elevation is only around 1 meter up or down, holding steady between 26 – 24 meters; again, the elevation at the Noteć is 24 meters.  Incidentally, at Brenkenhofswalde – literally “Brenkenhoff’s Forest” – there is no forest.  Likewise, at Franzthal – literally “Franz’s [Brenkenhoff’s] Valley” – there is no valley.

Magda already pointed out to us that we would notice the “shaky” nature of the ground.  The term “shaky” lost a bit in translation but we did indeed notice her point very quickly.  “Unstable” or “unsteady” might be better terms.  Thesaurus.com lists “jelly-like” as a synonym for shaky and indeed this might be a very good term to express Magda’s thought.  In many places in these villages we witnessed moments when the ground, due to its marshy nature, indeed felt “jelly-like” beneath the feet.

The local clay is yellow and therefore many buildings are built of yellow bricks.  Notably, buildings often bear testament to the unstable nature of the ground.  Walls in many places were heavily reinforced and even still, many had developed cracks when the foundation sagged under one side or another.  Larger barns were further reinforced with wall anchors.  Floors buckled and caved as the ground had shifted.  Clearly, the construction of stable structures in the lowlands was a challenge and perhaps buildings didn’t grow to be as old as they might in other environments.  Perhaps this was a reason why no 200-year-old Mennonite buildings still exist in the area when a fair number still do along the Vistula.  

The entire area seemed to be very lush and green.  While there were few large trees, many varieties of bushes and shrubs were everywhere with weeds, grasses, and vines, seemingly covering everything.  A couple standouts for me were hazelnut trees, which were common, as well as many apple trees.  In fact, wandering around the villages we were able to simply walk by apple trees and pick and eat ripe fruit.   

The layout of Głęboczek in particular struck me a bit odd because there was no road passing through the middle of the village where the houses stood.  The road ran along the southern perimeter, but the houses are generally aligned along a central canal.  Thus, houses have long lanes to the south out to the road.  Błotnica was originally set up in the same way but now a road has been built through the middle of the village and most houses have been rebuilt along that road.

Błotnica, Głęboczek, and environs

 

The Noteć River flows south and east of the villages, arcing to pass Głęboczek immediately to the east.  The Petri Canal, built about the time when the Mennonites arrived in the area, runs through both villages.  The canal is neither wide nor deep but provided crucial drainage for both villages (the original village houses were built along the Petri).  Today it is not well-maintained, and Magda pointed out that the neglect has had detrimental effects.

Petri Canal, Głęboczek, lot #26

 

Houses:

Magda was generally unconcerned with Błotnica since she knew we were looking for buildings which might stretch back to the early years of the 19th century.  Błotnica #18 is one of the oldest houses in the village; this was Brenkenhofswalde lot #11.  The house is one of the oldest in the village but stands in a completely different spot to the Mennonite house from the 1805 map.  The brick walls are buckled and patched because of the unstable nature of the ground.

In Głęboczek, however, many older houses still stand, and many stand in the same spots where Mennonite houses stood.  We visited Głęboczek #23 (equivalent to Franzthal #9), Głęboczek #21 (the more westerly of the two Franzthal #11s), Głęboczek #26/Franzthal #5, and Głęboczek #4/Franzthal #13.  All these buildings stand in the same spots where Mennonite houses stood but none are housebarns.  Construction was wattle and daub and the framing timbers were joined with mortise and tenon joints held secure with wooden pegs.  These buildings were probably built during the mid- to late-19th century, in the generation immediately following the Mennonite exodus.

Głęboczek #23

 

According to Zabytek, #21 was apparently the most notable old house in the village in 1987.  Again, the house lacks some essential Mennonite characteristics: it’s not a housebarn nor does it have a centrally located kitchen (czarna kuchnia).  A row of willow trees stands immediately east of the house which could have been planted by Mennonites but the structure itself is almost certainly not Mennonite-built.

Głęboczek #26/Franzthal #5 is actually the lot where my 6th great grandfather Ratzlaff lived so this was a particularly interesting spot for me.  The barn here apparently stands in almost the same location as the Mennonite housebarn from the 1805 map.  This structure was fairly typical for these villages and we saw a lot of similar barns.  The house here is large and in good condition but different to the other houses in that it has a second story.  It’s also wattle and daub construction held together with pegs.  The house faces east and the barn faces south so the yard was a tidy square.  Magda was good friends with the occupants, and they were very happy to show us even inside the house.  The Petri Canal passed just behind (north of) the barn and the farmyards were situated along this canal.  A pathway likely led along the edge of the canal in former days.  In order to reach the church, a few lots to the east, a walk along the canal would have been the most direct method.

Głęboczek #26/Franzthal #5

 

Churches:

The Brenkenhofswalde Mennonite church was built in 1778.  It was located off the row of village houses in the tip-top northeast corner of the village.  It stood about 25 meters due south from today’s Błotnica  church.  Today’s building, a fairly typical late-19th century Lutheran style brick building was built at the end of the 19th century and consecrated as a Catholic church in 1946.  Today it is the Catholic Church of St. Michael the Archangel but is not used due to the poor condition of the roof. 

Błotnica  church (left); Głęboczek church (right)

 

The Franzthal Mennonite church was built in 1787 and stood, apparently, at the same spot where today’s Głęboczek church stands, immediately north of the canal.  The Mennonite building survived until the interwar period.  Today’s building is still in use, but it strikes me as in very poor repair.  The floor is badly buckling and caving due to the unstable nature of the ground upon which it stands.  It’s a brick building, covered with lime mortar, and was consecrated as a Catholic church (Church of St. Barbara) in 1946.  The adjacent school building is built on a brick foundation.  Both church and school were likely built by the Lutherans in the mid-19th century.

We don’t know how the Mennonite churches would have looked but they would likely have been similar to other Vistula-area Mennonite churches from the early 19th century.  For instance, these folks were in close communion with their brethren in Przechówko, Schönsee, Sady, etc., so their church buildings could have looked similar.  Given the population of Mennonites in these villages, churches would have needed to accommodate around 150 people each.[14]  These Netzebruch Mennonites had close ties to brethren in the Dutch Lowlands and generous Dutch Mennonites contributed funds toward the building of both churches.

Cemeteries:

On the 1805 map of Brenkenhofwalde, we see a small field immediately north from the church building which indicates the cemetery.  If we trust the map, the space could be measured at approximately 1800 square meters.  Today, this is roughly the space occupied by the St. Michael the Archangel church building and yard.  No gravemarkers can be seen here today.

Brenkenhofswalde cemetery area (left) with corresponding (red) area marked for modern-day Błotnica  (right)

Documents at Zabytek.pl indicate the old Franzthal cemetery was at the churchyard.[15]  The cemetery encompasses an area of approximately 1500 square meters with the church building occupying the southwest corner of the space.  Again, no gravemarkers can be seen here today.


Original Franzthal cemetery (left) and with corresponding (red) area marked for modern-day Głęboczek (right)

 

Apparently, at some point after the Mennonites left, burial places were moved to new locations, up on higher ground and out of these lowlands.  Magda took us to the nearby cemeteries which likely served the Lutheran population of the villages during the 19th century.  Both of these were located north from the churchyards, fairly close to the Stare Kurowo road.  Both lie in ruins, heavily overgrown by weeds and bushes.  The Błotnica  cemetery contained many gravestone remnants but no obviously legible inscriptions.  In the Głęboczek cemetery, however, we found several gravestones bearing German names.  Some of these names we even know belonged to Lutheran families who bought out the Mennonites when they vacated in 1830s.

Conclusions

Political events such as the Partitions of Poland and the Napoleonic expansions created an environment which spelled an end to the Mennonites’ time in the Netzebruch.  A quick listing of important events can explain:

·         1813: the Prussian government passed a military conscription law which required all males to register for military duty.

·         16 May 1830: the Mennonite Edict of 1789 took effect in West Prussia. This edict gave Mennonites a choice between military service or paying an extra tax/accepting the loss of some civil rights, including the right to buy land.  Mennonites filed an entreaty with King Frederick William III to restore the terms of their original charter, but the king denied the appeal.[16]

·         Summer 1832: 40 Netzebruch families petitioned the Russian government for permission to immigrate.  Permission was granted in autumn, 1833.

·         Summer of 1834: 28 Mennonite families as well as 10 Lutheran families, left for Russia.[17]

Some of the Netzebruch Mennonites began to move into Volyn by the first decade or two of the 19th century, while the balance liquidated by 1834 in favor of the Molotschna.  Many who moved to Molotchna helped to establish Gnadenfeld and indeed, the ex-Brenkenhofswalde Mennonites became very influential Molotschna-wide, especially in religious and educational matters.



[1] Heirs, Homann, Map of Poland – Geographicus, 1750.

[2] Gilly, Spezialkarte von Suedpreussen; Biblioteka Cyfrowa Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego; 1803.

[3] Buller, Bob, “Bullertime” Mennonites in Neumark 1 and 1a: https://bullertime.blogspot.com/2016/06/mennonites-in-neumark-1.html accessed 29 March 2025.

[4] Engelien and Henning, History of the City of Landsberg on the Warta, Landsberg a.d. Warthe, 1857, Pp 200-209. Also see, Henderson, W.O., Studies in the Economic Policy of Frederick the Great, Frank Cass & Co, 1963, Pp 82-3.

[5] Mantau, Rudolf, Die Siedlungsentwicklung im Oberen- und Unteren Netzebruch. 1935/36, p56.

[6] Seutter, 1725, Brandenburgicus Pomeraniae

[7] Fadden, 1816, Map of the Central States of Europe Situate between France and Russia

[8] Hege, Christian. "Netzebruch (Poland)." Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. 1957. Web. 29 Mar 2025. https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Netzebruch_(Poland)&oldid=144474.

[9] The late John D. Richert compiled these lists c2023 and gave copy of his notes which remain unpublished at this time.

[10] Berlin, 22 March 1779; “The Mennonites in West Prussia Deserve Special Attention”, Augsburgische Ordinari Postzeitung von Staats-, helehrten, historisch- u. okonomischen Neuigkeiten.

[12] https://zabytek.pl/en/mapa, , accessed 29 March 2025.

[13] Maps of Mennonite Villages in Neumark, Brandenburg, Prussia, 1805; Mennonite Library and Archives; https://mla.bethelks.edu/metadata/neumark_maps.php; 21 March 2025

[16] Klassen, Peter J, Mennonites in Early Modern Poland and Prussia, Johns Hopkins Univ Press, Baltimore, 2009. P 87.

[17] Jantzen, Mark. 2010. Mennonite German Soldiers: Nation, Religion, and Family in the Prussian East, 1772–1880. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press. P 117.